Better Homes and Gardens Home Improvement Challenge 2009

By: Danny Lipford
Pam Schulz and Clark Dikeman of Culver City, California, standing in front of their home addition.

Pam Schulz and Clark Dikeman of Culver City, California, with their winning home addition.

Watch Full Episode

There were over 3,100 entries in the 2009 Better Homes and Gardens Home Improvement Challenge. Entries in the contest were rated based on appearance, creativity, function, and use of materials. Here are the winners.


Pam Schulz and Clark Dikeman of Culver City, California, won for their kitchen and bathroom addition to their home. The kitchen features a retro design that includes a 1950s stove, vaulted wood ceiling, clerestory windows above the cabinets, and quartz countertops. Best of all, eco-friendly materials were used throughout the addition.


Ann Steenwyk of Sheboygan, Wisconsin, removed a wall in her kitchen to open up the space. The simple, clean lines of the white cabinets, combined with great color choices, give the room an open, airy feeling.


Meg Kopald of Shelburne, Vermont, won the bath category by taking in an existing closet to enlarge the room and bring in more light. The renovated bath features his and her pedestal sinks along with a walk-in shower.


James Little of Naples, Florida, took the honors in the decorating category for his 1,400-square-foot ranch style home built in the 1970s. Working with a palette of blues and browns, he used a variety of textures and accessories to keep the rooms from appearing too one-dimensional.

Exterior Facelift

Sonjia and Bob McKelvey of Belpre, Ohio, were the winners in the exterior home facelift category. With the help of their architect son, they transformed the exterior of their home into a quaint cottage. Details such as a winding paver walk, shingle siding, and special eave brackets added greatly to the curb appeal.

Project under $5,000

Jackie Kalin of Valparaiso, Indiana, used her artistic abilities to take home the award for projects under $5,000 for her unique bathroom renovation. The mosaic mural was made by gluing thousands of individual pieces of glass and mirrors to the wall.

Green Improvements

Laura Stukel of Elmhurst, Illinois, added insulation and energy efficient windows—along with a host of other energy saving features—to capture the green improvement prize. Nontoxic paints and cabinets were used on the 1960s home to improve the indoor air quality.

Outdoor Improvements

Jacque and Rick Bailey of Brecksville, Ohio, were the winners of the outdoor improvements category for their beautifully landscaped backyard. The design by landscape architect Peggy Brown was carried out by contractor Mark Huscroft. It includes an expansive stone patio—complete with outdoor kitchen—flanked by stone walls, a potting shed, and an impressive water feature.


Grand prize winners Dana Liston and David Ellis of Venice, California, won in the renovation category by transforming a 1,350-square-foot, 1913 bungalow into their dream house. The couple worked with contractor and neighbor Mox Moeschler on the renovation while doing much of the work themselves. The project includes front and side porches, a family room featuring built-in bookcases and window seats, and a remodeled master bedroom and bath.

Photos courtesy of Better Homes and Gardens magazine.

Other Tips from This Episode

Nail Apron Liners

Simple Solutions with Joe Truini:
Nail Apron Liners

Cloth nail aprons are great for DIY projects around the home, but with only two pockets, they usually can’t hold everything you need. By cutting the top off plastic quart oil containers, you can make interchangeable liners for the pockets of the apron to hold different size nails and screws.

Behr Paint and Primer in One

Best New Products with Jodi Marks:
Behr Paint and Primer in One

Behr Premium Plus Ultra paint eliminates the need for separate primer and topcoat by combining both into one can. The 100% acrylic latex paint comes in several sheens in both interior and exterior paints and is available at The Home Depot.

Reducing Meat Consumption Saves Water

Thinking Green with Danny Lipford:
Reducing Meat Consumption

According to a study by the University of California, it takes over 5,200 gallons of water to produce one pound of beef, that’s about the same amount of water as you use in an entire year of daily showers. Reducing the amount of meat you consume by even a small amount saves a lot of water.



Please Leave a Comment

4 Comments on “Better Homes and Gardens Home Improvement Challenge 2009”

You can follow comments to this article by subscribing to the RSS news feed with your favorite feed reader.

  • Official Comment:

    Ben Erickson Says:
    September 9th, 2011 at 10:04 am

    Hi Sally,
    The winners were written up in the September 2009 issue of Better Homes & Gardens magazine. In the resource guide on page 270 concerning the article on the Exterior Facelift winner, all it says is: “Exterior paint, Woodscapes solid color stain, custom mixed colors–Sherwin Williams.” You might want to try and contact Better Homes & Gardens magazine and see if they have any more information on it.

  • Sally Gantt Says:
    September 8th, 2011 at 4:48 pm

    I am desperate to know the exterior color in the EXTERIOR FACELIFT WINNER 2009 contest as well as what type of materials were used. Can you please help?

    March 15th, 2010 at 11:38 am


  • j. Wilson Says:
    September 27th, 2009 at 2:18 pm

    I would like to see some ideas about adding on a front porch

We want to hear from you! In addition to posting comments on articles and videos, you can also send your comments and questions to us on our contact page or at (800) 946-4420. While we can't answer them all, we may use your question on our Today's Homeowner radio or TV show, or online at

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.